The conversation around Provider Directories – integrated provider data as available to patients has really taken off with #CMS Health Tech Ecosystem taking the initiatives and inviting very openly the developers, tech companies and experts in the healthcare field. Kudos to #CMS for being so open about inviting the best of minds who are passionate about making an impact in the ‘right’ direction.
Therefore, after a year or so of focused development around this effort, ME – the Patient wants to know …
Can the solution reliably answer these five 5 questions using real provider data?
| # | What the Patient Needs to Know | Example |
| 1 | Who are you? | Jane Smith, MD |
| 2 | What do you do? | Family Medicine, Cardiology, Behavioral Health |
| 3 | Where can I see you? | Location/address + phone |
| 4 | Do you take my insurance? | Health plans/networks accepted |
| 5 | Can I see you? | Accepting new patients + how to make an appointment |
The patient’s five simple questions directly to the provider-profile data needed to produce the answer
| Patient Needs to Know | Provider Profile Data Elements That Feed It |
| 1. WHO are you? | Legal name; professional/display name; credentials/degree; provider type; photograph |
| 2. WHAT do you do? | Primary practice specialty; additional specialties; subspecialty; areas of clinical expertise; services/conditions treated; age/population served |
| 3. WHERE can I see you? | Practice/facility name; physical service location; address; phone; office hours; whether provider actively sees patients at that location; telehealth availability |
| 4. Do you take MY INSURANCE? | Payer; health plan; specific network/product; provider-to-group/TIN affiliation; provider-to-location affiliation; effective/termination dates; network participation status |
| 5. CAN I see you? | Accepting new patients Y/N; appointment phone/URL; scheduling method; appointment availability; referral required Y/N; patient population/age restrictions; accessibility/language needs |
The important data relationship
The directory should not simply ask: “What information do we have about this provider?”
It should ask: “What data do we need to accurately answer the patient’s five questions?”
With integrated data improves provider directory focus and the role provider directories play, the data architecture becomes:
PROVIDER PROFILE DATA
↓
Identity → Clinical Practice → Location → Network → Access
↓
PATIENT DIRECTORY
That is the patient-facing foundation.
Everything else—NPI, taxonomy, license, credentialing status, enrollment identifiers, etc.is infrastructure supporting those five answers, not information a patient should have to understand in order to find the right provider.
Location cannot just be an address attached to a provider. CRITICAL
It needs a relationship:
Provider + Specialty/Service + Location + Plan/Network + Availability
For example, Dr. Smith may practice Cardiology at Location A, perform Interventional Cardiology at Location B, participate with a particular payer product at A but not B, and accept new patients only at A.
That relationship is what makes a provider directory genuinely useful rather than merely a collection of demographic data provider.
So to those Developers the Real Test is: Can the solution reliably answer these five questions using real provider data?
| Patient Question | Readiness Test | Pass Criteria |
| WHO are you? | Search for a known provider by name | Correct provider, credentials and provider type are returned; duplicates/aliases handled |
| WHAT do you do? | Search by the service/specialty a patient would actually use | Provider appears for the appropriate specialty/service—not merely because a technical classification happens to match |
| WHERE can I see you? | Search by ZIP/city/location | Only locations where the provider actually sees patients are returned, with correct phone/address |
| Do you take MY INSURANCE? | Select a specific payer and product/network | Provider is shown only where the provider/group/location relationship is actually participating in that product |
| CAN I see you? | Ask for a provider accepting new patients | Current acceptance status, restrictions and scheduling pathway are available and accurate |
Knock, Knock … Did you PASS this Test?
https://www.cms.gov/initiatives/health-technology-ecosystem/overview/interoperability-framework
https://www.cms.gov/initiatives/health-technology-ecosystem/overview